Savannah Guthrie’s life changed forever when she learned her 84-year-old mother, Nancy Guthrie, had been abducted in the middle of the night on Jan. 31. “Savannah’s whole world was turned upside down in an instant,” a source tells the National Examiner. “She was destroyed — but she stayed strong. Because she has her faith.”
Savannah, a devout Baptist, has repeatedly referenced that faith in desperate public pleas to the kidnappers and in messages to supporters across America.
Savannah Guthrie/Instagram
Just one day after Nancy’s terrifying abduction from her Tucson, Ariz., home, Savannah, 54, posted a solemn, two-word social media message: “Please Pray.”
Days later, on Feb. 4, the Today host fought through tears as she thanked supporters for their prayers, telling fans in a video, “We feel them, and we continue to believe that [Nancy] feels them, too.”
Then she spoke directly to her mother. “You are God’s precious daughter, Nancy,” she said while flanked by siblings Annie, 56, and Camron, 61. “We believe and know that even in this valley He is with you. Everyone is looking for you, Mommy, everywhere. We will not rest. Your children will not rest until we are together again.”
Eleven grueling days later, on Feb. 15, the Georgetown University–trained lawyer took to social media to appeal to whatever goodness might still reside in the kidnappers’ hardened hearts.
“We still have hope, and we still believe. It’s never too late,” she said to them. “You’re not lost or alone, and it is never too late to do the right thing. We are here. We believe. We believe in the essential goodness of every human being, and it’s never too late.”
A Shocking Twist
Pima County Sheriff’s Depart MEGA
As the world now knows, Nancy Guthrie was snatched from the home in which she’s lived for the last 50 years and where she raised Savannah, Annie and Camron with her late husband, Charlie, a former mining engineer who moved his family there from Australia in 1975.
The Mega Agency
Droplets of Nancy’s blood were found on her doorstep and — in a twist no one saw coming — a shocking and horrifying image of her alleged abductor emerged on Feb. 10 showing a masked, armed man on her doorstep the night she was taken.
A second image also snapped by Nancy’s doorbell camera revealed the alleged assailant stalked the home prior to the kidnapping.
Getty Images
As the Examiner went to press, police had not identified any suspects or made any arrests — this, despite a $1.1 million reward plus thousands of tips. But Savannah never gave up. “She’s said she will never lose faith that her mother will be found,” says the source. “From the moment she learned her mother was missing Savannah has leaned on God and drawn strength from Him. Her life continues to be a living hell — there’s no peace, no closure — but she will never crumble. She’s too strong.”
The Greatest Gift
Savannah Guthrie/Instagram
Savannah was born on Dec. 27, 1971, as the third child of Charlie and Nancy — deeply devout Baptists who took their family to church three times a week. Charlie was a man of “deep faith and conviction,” Savannah has said, while Nancy was “a woman of deep conviction, a good and faithful servant.”
“The greatest gift my mother gave me was faith and belief in God,” she’s shared on TODAY. “It changed my whole life.
“God was the sixth member of our family,” she added. “There were five of us. As my sister Annie says it, ‘God was the sixth.’ ”
Savannah Guthrie/Instagram
According to insiders, the Guthrie family rallied around each other and drew strength from God after Charlie’s untimely death in 1988 at just 49 from a heart attack when Savannah was 16 years old.
“I remember being asked by friends how can you still believe [given his death],” Savannah once said, according to TODAY. “And I remember saying, ‘Oh no. This is when I need Him the most. I can’t lose God and my dad at the same time.’ ”
In her 2024 book, Mostly on What God Does: Reflections on Seeking and Finding His Love Everywhere, Savannah said God was “taking care” of her “every need” and explained that faith can serve as a source of both strength and perseverance in the face of crisis or adversity.
Getty Images
“Going through deep crises, profound adversity — those are the make-or-break moments for faith; they can be existential threats to your belief, or they can be extraordinary teachers. Sometimes they are both, and not always at the same time.”
Her faith has also driven her, in part, to the lofty perch she occupies atop the TV news world. “Being a journalist, you have to realize, was never about fame or glory for Savannah,” says the insider. “It was always about using her gifts to serve others — and in, turn, serve Him.”
Turning the Page
Getty Images
Beverly Hills psychiatrist Dr. Carole Lieberman, who has not treated Savannah, tells the Examiner that, generally speaking, “the stronger a person’s faith in God, the better they will be able to weather adversity, because they always feel like God is going to protect them, or their loved ones, or they are able to [see] the adversity as part of a divine plan.”
Insiders say Savannah and her siblings have given up all but the faintest of hopes her Nancy will be returned alive.
“Seeing Savannah back in the Today studio [on March 5] was a sign she has begun to move forward, or at least begun to think about the next step,” says the source. “Her faith will see her through this. It will nourish and feed her as she wonders why and fights to carry on.”