Melissa Gilbert’s world was shattered when her husband, Timothy Busfield, was accused of child sex crimes — but the Little House on the Prairie legend is standing by her man as he fights the stomach-churning charges, sources say.
Getty Images
“Melissa is understandably in pieces and totally beside herself right now,” an insider says. “She loves Timothy. She’s spent years telling everyone what a mild-mannered and wholesome gentleman he is and that he’s the soul mate she wants to grow old with.”
Melissa’s fairytale life with The West Wing alum — with whom she shares a home in New York’s bucolic Catskills — turned into a nightmare on Jan. 9 when an arrest warrant was issued in New Mexico for Busfield, who’s now facing two counts of criminal sexual contact of a minor and one count of child abuse, according to The Hollywood Reporter.
Bernalillo County Detention Center
Lawmen have accused the 68-year-old of inappropriate behavior toward twin boys, now 11, while the children worked on director Busfield’s TV series The Cleaning Lady in 2022. He has denied the charges and reportedly alleged he was told by an actor that the kids’ mom was out for “revenge” after they weren’t hired for the final season.
But the warrant also includes his admission that it’s “highly likely” he picked up and tickled kids on the set, citing its “playful environment,” per US Weekly.
Bernalillo County Detention Center
Busfield’s attorney says the actor is determined to clear his name and notes an outside investigator hired by Warner Bros. “found no corroborating evidence” his client “engaged in inappropriate conduct or that he was ever alone with the twins on set,” according to TMZ. In fact, the report states, “Every witness was ‘shocked’ by the allegations that Mr. Busfield engaged in inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature or otherwise, especially toward minor children.”
The lawyer further says Busfield voluntarily submitted to an independent polygraph examination regarding the allegations — and passed.
The suspect drove to Albuquerque and surrendered to lawmen four days after the warrant emerged. But before Busfield turned himself in, he recorded a video at his lawyer’s office in which he professed his innocence.
In the clip, the actor vows, “I’m gonna confront these lies. They’re horrible.” He goes on, “They’re all lies, and I did not do anything to those little boys, and I’m gonna fight it. I’m gonna fight it with a great team, and I’m gonna be exonerated, I know I am, because this is all so wrong and all lies.”
As Busfield was being processed by officials in New Mexico, armed federal agents broke down the door of the couple’s New York property with a battering ram — but appeared to leave empty-handed after approximately 20 minutes, according to reports.
The performer, who has no children with Melissa but is a dad of three from previous relationships, is currently being held without bond at the Metropolitan Detention Center outside Albuquerque. In a letter, Melissa called on a judge to protect her “sweet husband” in jail. Meanwhile, she was named as a witness in the sex abuse case.
Getty Images
Melissa’s rep Ame Van Iden says the former Screen Actors Guild president’s focus is on “supporting and caring for their very large family as they navigate this moment.”
The spokesperson further shares, “Melissa stands with and supports her husband and will address the public at an appropriate time. We ask that their privacy be respected,” per Entertainment Weekly.
The former Dancing With the Stars contestant was previously wed to filmmaker Bo Brinkman from 1988 to 1994 and actor Bruce Boxleitner from 1995 to 2011, and shares one son with each ex.
Getty Images
Following her devastating divorce with Bruce, she binged on plastic surgery, hooked up with a French boytoy and admitted in 2022 to Page Six, “It was like I lost my mind.”
If Busfield, who she wed in 2013, is convicted, it could lead to another meltdown for Melissa.
And it’s worse than anyone knows. Adding to her heartache, sources say, are emerging allegations about Busfield’s past. New Mexico prosecutors state a California father recently reached out to claim Busfield kissed his then 16-year-old daughter and touched her intimate parts “several years ago” when she auditioned at Sacramento’s B Street Theatre, co-founded by the accused — and begged the family not to report the incident if he received therapy.
And back in 1994, a 17-year-old female extra on Little Big League accused castmate Busfield of plying her with booze and sexually assaulting her. Busfield, who denied the allegations, settled the girl’s lawsuit for an undisclosed amount. The actor was also ordered to pay about $150,000 to a Minneapolis law firm after a judge rejected his claim that the legal eagles fabricated the teen’s case against him. The figure was to reimburse the firm Messerli & Kramer for the amount it cost to defend itself in a defamation suit filed by Busfield. He later appealed the costs award, and the parties settled the case.
Busfield was not criminally charged in connection with either of the two purported incidents, and his lawyer notes, “The allegations were never challenged, they were never proved, and they’re 25 years old. And there doesn’t seem to be any connection between these allegations regarding women 25 years ago and the allegations regarding these young boys.”
And in 2012, a 28-year-old gal accused Busfield of battery, alleging he slipped his hands under her clothes in an LA movie theater and touched her genitals for four minutes. Prosecutors declined to pursue a case, and there was no civil suit. Busfield claimed the encounter was consensual.
Meanwhile, friends, fans and colleagues are expressing support for Melissa.
Getty Images
One Day at a Time’s Glenn Scarpelli, 59, posted a throwback pic of himself and his fellow former child star on Instagram with the caption: “Loving my ol’ Friend Melissa Gilbert right now. No commentary, just love… That is all… ”
Glenn Scarpelli/Instagram
Apparently some of her Little House costars have also reached out to offer their love and support, says the insider.
And fans, of course, are in her corner. “Praying for her,” one wrote, while another — citing Melissa’s screen nickname on Little House — declared, “No one messes with our Half Pint!”