For more than a decade, Hargitay, 62, and Meloni, 65, had been at the heart of the NBC procedural as Olivia Benson and Elliot Stabler.
But when Meloni exited the series in 2011 after 12 seasons, Hargitay suddenly found herself stepping into a much bigger role.
“Chris was number 1, Mariska was number 2,” Ice-T, who plays Odafin “Fin” Tutuola, told Variety on August 19. “Chris had notes on every scene, and he was kind of in charge.”
He continued, “When you have somebody like that on the set, everybody else is comfortable. ‘I’ll let you do it. Less work for me!’ When Chris left, Mariska took that spot.”
Hargitay recalled that the transition presented a major challenge.
ZUMAPRESS.com / MEGA
“It was a question for everybody: Can she hold the show? Can she lead the show? Nobody knew. It was one of those moments of stepping up,” she explained. “And sometimes you don’t step up until there’s a space.”
Hargitay also said she tried to help broker a solution before Meloni’s departure because she felt his exit had not ended well.
Meloni previously told Men’s Health that his departure came after contract negotiations broke down. The actor said he tried to negotiate both his salary and the number of episodes he would appear in, but the two sides were unable to reach an agreement.
Despite the professional split, their friendship survived. Meloni, 65, eventually returned as Stabler in 2021 before going on to headline Law & Order: Organized Crime.
Hargitay, meanwhile, remained at the center of SVU and is now shooting Season 28 of the long-running series.
She is also set to take on another major television role when she hosts the Emmy Awards on September 14.