Entertainment

Margaret Hamilton, Idina Menzel and More Stars Who Made Broadway’s Favorite Witch Wickedly Memorable

Mark McGarry

Published

on

Walt Disney Pictures | Loew’s Incorporated | Universal Pictures

From gravity-defying high notes to pointy-hat powerhouse performances, these seven actresses made Broadway’s favorite witch wickedly unforgettable.

Idina Menzel – Wicked (2003)

Getty Images

Idina gives first life to Elphaba in the Broadway “prequel” adaptation that showcases the friendship between the green and outcast Elphaba and the popular Glinda, played by Broadway legend Kristin Chenoweth.

Margaret Hamilton – The Wizard of Oz (1939)

Loew’s Incorporated

Margaret sets the bar high with her portrayal in the classic film starring Judy Garland as Dorothy Gale. Her snarled warning to Dorothy, “I’ll get you … and your little dog, too” has been a pop culture icon ever since.

Mila Kunis – Oz the Great and Powerful (2013)

Walt Disney Pictures

Perhaps the humblest of the stars, Mila played Theodora, who becomes the Wicked Witch of the West in a totally different take on the story. Mila felt intimidated to play Margaret Hamilton’s legendary role, once admitting, “I didn’t want to ruin it, and I didn’t want to re-create it, and I didn’t want to re-interpret it. And so, in order for me to wrap my head around it, I had to make sense of her origin.”

Miss Piggy – The Muppets’ Wizard of Oz (2005)

The Muppets Holding Company

Of those who’ve played the Wicked Witch, there is no bigger “ham” than the egocentric Miss Piggy! This version sees her trying to convince the Wizard to make her a singing star, and features Ashanti as Dorothy, Jeffrey Tambor as the Wizard, David Alan Grier as Uncle Henry and Queen Latifah as Auntie Em.

Mary J. Blige – The Wiz Live! (2015)

Universal Television

Playing Wicked Witch Evillene, Mary heads an all-star cast in a live NBC broadcast that costarred Uzo Aduba as Glinda, Ne-Yo as the Tin Man and Amber Riley as Addapearle. David Alan Grier and Queen Latifah also return, but in different roles — Grier played the Cowardly Lion, and Latifah played the titular character the Wiz. Mary shares this about playing Hamilton’s role: “I didn’t take it away from the traditional way. But I just did a little ‘Mary’ on it.”

Mabel King – The Wiz (1978)

Getty Images

In the film adaptation of the Broadway musical that put a new spin on the story, Mabel more than holds her own in a superstar cast that includes Diana Ross as Dorothy and Michael Jackson as the Scarecrow.

Cynthia Erivo – Wicked (2024) and Wicked: For Good (2025)

Universal Pictures

Cynthia takes over Idina Menzel’s iconic “Defying Gravity” role as Elphaba in the box office block-busters that split the Broadway show into two films. The musical movies also star Ariana Grande as Glinda, Jeff Goldblum as the Wizard, Jonathan Bailey as Fiyero and Michelle Yeoh as Madam Morrible.

Trending News

Real Estate4 days ago

Jenny McCarthy and Donnie Wahlberg Sell Illinois House for $2.7M After Revealing They’re Relocating

Exclusive5 days ago

King Charles’ ‘Frail and Sickly’ Appearance Sparks Concern He’s ‘Overdoing It’ Amid Cancer Battle

Exclusive4 days ago

Willie Nelson Wants to Ensure There Isn’t an ‘Ugly War’ Over His $20M Estate When ‘His Time Comes’

Celebrity News3 days ago

Jenny McCarthy’s Son Shares Emotional Goodbye to Childhood Home After Sale, Vows to Buy It Back

Exclusive2 days ago

Prince Harry ‘Wishes People Would Show’ Meghan Markle ‘A Little Kindness’ Amid Her Father’s Scandal

Royals2 days ago

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Enjoy First Public Family Outing With Archie and Lilibet in London

Celebrity News3 days ago

Christina Ricci Reveals ‘Mermaids’ Costar Cher Hasn’t Spoken to Her in Years: ‘She Holds a Grudge’

Celebrity News3 days ago

Roseanne Barr Has No ‘Desire’ for Intimacy After Being Celibate for 14 Years: ‘Cost Me Everything’

CELEBRITY5 days ago

Tom Arnold Clarifies Calling People His Age ‘Disgusting’ After Revealing Why He Hasn’t Dated in Years

News4 days ago

Pope Leo XIV Hit Near the Eye by Flying Rosary Thrown While Greeting Crowds During Peru Visit

Exclusive3 days ago

King Charles Is ‘Absolutely Livid’ That Ex-Prince Andrew Has Been Spilling ‘Royal Gossip’ at Parties

Celebrity Deaths1 day ago

Patrick Stewart’s Body Was Water Cremated Following Death at Age 86