Entertainment

‘Gone With the Wind’ Cast Members Reveal the Struggles That Nearly Derailed the Beloved 1939 Classic

Mark McGarry

Published

on

Getty Images

Clark Gable didn’t want to cry. During the making of Gone With the Wind, the Oscar winner worried about the scene in which Rhett Butler breaks down in tears at the death of his darling daughter, Bonnie, after a horse-riding accident. “He never cried on the screen before, and it became an obsession with him,” recalled Olivia de Havilland, who played Melanie Wilkes. “He didn’t think it was masculine for a man to cry.” He got so panicked, she said, “One day he confided in me, ‘Olivia, I can’t do it. I’m just going to have to quit!’ I convinced him that tears denoted strength of character, not weakness. It turned out to be one of the most memorable scenes in the movie.”

Getty Images

The truth is, at that moment, or at many others during the making of the epic 1939 Civil War extravaganza, the film could have fallen apart. But against all odds, the pieces fell into place and it became one of the greatest movies ever made — and one of the most expensive at $4.25 million. “The casting, the cinematography, the music, the production values, the screenplay — it’s just the epitome of golden age Hollywood,” says John Wiley, author of The Scarlett Letters: The Making of the Film Gone With the Wind. Members of the cast and those closest to them previously opened up to Closer about the behind-the-scenes drama, controversies and jealousies that threatened to ruin the film.

Getty Images

Margaret Mitchell’s 1936 novel earned a Pulitzer Prize and was a massive best seller. And as a result, everyone had an opinion about who should play charming Rhett Butler and Southern vixen Scarlett O’Hara. Mitchell herself reportedly got so fed up with the debate, she joked that Groucho Marx embodied Rhett’s qualities best. But the book’s fans unanimously called for handsome, 38-year-old Clark Gable. “The public interest in my playing Rhett puzzled me,” said Gable, and he didn’t leap at the chance. “The book was so popular, he wasn’t sure he could live up to those expectations,” Wiley says.

Getty Images

Casting Scarlett also caused a media frenzy. The search took two years, but British newcomer Vivien Leigh, 25, never doubted her chances. “I shall play Scarlett O’Hara,” she said. “Wait and see.” But finding the perfect actress was expensive. “The Scarlett O’Hara Wars [became] a sort of stunt of looking at various actresses that cost something like $10,000 — an exorbitant fee at the time,” says film critic Joe Neumaier. Over two dozen women were considered, including Bette Davis and Katharine Hepburn. “It came down to Paulette Goddard and Vivien Leigh,” Neumaier adds. “Vivien came up out of nowhere, and she had a great story — she was involved with Laurence Olivier. All of that became part of the excitement.”

Getty Images

De Havilland said she took on the role of Melanie because “I sensed the film would have a much longer life than others — perhaps as long as five years!” In another first, however, Olivia lost the Best Supporting Actress Oscar to costar Hattie McDaniel, who played Mammy and became the first African American to win an Academy Award. “I have heard that Olivia said it really hurt her feelings,” says Wiley, “but looking back she realizes what an important thing that win was.”

McDaniel had appeared in a few films prior to GWTW, but her great-grandnephew, Kevin John Goff, says, “It was really her big opportunity.” The role of Scarlett’s fiercely protective maid didn’t come without controversy, though, including complaints from the African American community, which was tired of seeing Black actors playing “the help.” But Hattie, the daughter of former slaves, said: “Why should I complain about making $700 a week playing a maid? If I didn’t, I’d be making $7 a week being one.”

Getty Images

Once principal shooting began in January 1939, more problems arose. The film went through three directors. The first, George Cukor, “did not see eye to eye” with producer David O. Selznick, says Wiley. But Gable also wanted to see Cukor go. “Clark felt Cukor was a ‘woman’s director’ and would throw the film to Leigh,” explains Wiley. So Selznick brought on Victor Fleming, who came right from directing The Wizard of Oz and whom Gable considered a “man’s director.” But Olivia and Vivien were not happy: Both women went to Cukor and “secretly sought his help all during the filming,” De Havilland said. (Sam Wood was brought in for 24 days when Fleming allegedly suffered a nervous breakdown.)

In addition to swapping directors, Selznick fought to keep Rhett’s famous last line, “Frankly, my dear, I don’t give a damn,” when the censors wanted it out. “Selznick tried make the case that the line would be missed,” Wiley says. In one draft of the script, the line was changed to, “Frankly, my dear, I don’t care.”

Fleming was threatened with a $5,000 fine if Gable said the original line, because swearing wasn’t allowed. When Fleming was told about the fine he said, “Go ahead, I don’t care, I’ll pay it!” and he put the line in, and it turned out to be a classic!

Getty Images

Even so, the controversies didn’t end after the last line was spoken. For one thing, McDaniel wasn’t invited to the Atlanta premiere. This seems shocking today, but Neumaier explains, “Since 1939 was only about 70 years after the end of the Civil War, it was still a raw time.” Again, Hattie seemed resigned. “She understood how the South was,” her nephew explains. “But it had to hurt. I call her a brave soldier, because she kept moving forward.” Even if she had gone to Atlanta, adds Wiley, “Not only could she not have stayed at the Georgian Terrace Hotel with the other stars, she could not have sat in Loew’s Grand Theatre.”

Two months later, McDaniel had her historic win. “It was definitely a moral victory,” Goff says. But even at the Oscars in Los Angeles, “She was seated at a table back by the kitchen,” Wiley says. Sadly, McDaniel’s Academy Award has disappeared. “It’s been missing for 45-plus years,” Goff says. It was lost from Howard University — McDaniel had bequeathed it to the historic black college at her death from breast cancer in 1952 — after the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. “There were a lot of riots, buildings were burning, and the Oscar hasn’t been seen since,” explains Goff.

Getty Images

Still, nearly 87 years after GWTW first blazed onto the screen, the film is as remarkable as ever. It won 10 Oscars and is the highest-grossing movie in history, earning $1.6 billion at the box office (adjusted for inflation). “It’s Hollywood at its best,” says Wiley. “It’s how movies used to be made.”

Mickey Kuhn, who played Melanie’s son Beau, agreed: “It was one of the first truly memorable movies. There wasn’t another studio that had the guts to do it. It’s a thrill to have been associated with probably the greatest movie of its time.”

Trending News

Real Estate4 days ago

Jenny McCarthy and Donnie Wahlberg Sell Illinois House for $2.7M After Revealing They’re Relocating

Exclusive5 days ago

King Charles’ ‘Frail and Sickly’ Appearance Sparks Concern He’s ‘Overdoing It’ Amid Cancer Battle

Exclusive4 days ago

Willie Nelson Wants to Ensure There Isn’t an ‘Ugly War’ Over His $20M Estate When ‘His Time Comes’

Celebrity News3 days ago

Jenny McCarthy’s Son Shares Emotional Goodbye to Childhood Home After Sale, Vows to Buy It Back

Exclusive2 days ago

Prince Harry ‘Wishes People Would Show’ Meghan Markle ‘A Little Kindness’ Amid Her Father’s Scandal

Royals2 days ago

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Enjoy First Public Family Outing With Archie and Lilibet in London

Celebrity News3 days ago

Christina Ricci Reveals ‘Mermaids’ Costar Cher Hasn’t Spoken to Her in Years: ‘She Holds a Grudge’

Celebrity News3 days ago

Roseanne Barr Has No ‘Desire’ for Intimacy After Being Celibate for 14 Years: ‘Cost Me Everything’

CELEBRITY5 days ago

Tom Arnold Clarifies Calling People His Age ‘Disgusting’ After Revealing Why He Hasn’t Dated in Years

News4 days ago

Pope Leo XIV Hit Near the Eye by Flying Rosary Thrown While Greeting Crowds During Peru Visit

Exclusive3 days ago

King Charles Is ‘Absolutely Livid’ That Ex-Prince Andrew Has Been Spilling ‘Royal Gossip’ at Parties

Celebrity Deaths1 day ago

Patrick Stewart’s Body Was Water Cremated Following Death at Age 86