“Obviously it was an impulsive thing to put myself forward. [Colbert] asked my advice and I said, ‘What about me?'” Costello, 72, revealed while speaking on the Rolling Stone Music Now podcast on Sunday, October 4. “And I think he thought I was joking. And I said, ‘No, I’m not joking.'”
Costello thought the gig would allow his band to continue to make records and work on things while not being on tour.
He added: “I saw… that they had saved their own lives and those of their family around them by coming off the road and basing themselves. I thought maybe that would be good for us.”
As it turned out, the offer was not taken seriously and it never happened.
Costello thinks it would have been a big ask to expect his Imposters bandmates to relocate to New York City.
Instead, Jon Batiste, 39, served as bandleader from the show’s debut in 2015 to 2022.
After he left, the spot was filled by Louis Cato, 41, until the show ended last May.
Costello, who has 19-year-old twin sons Dexter and Frank with his wife, jazz musician Diana Krall, was on the final show with Colbert, 62, and the pair played music together.
They signed off with his hit “Jump Up,” and later played the Beatles’ “Hello Goodbye” alongside Paul McCartney and bandleaders Baptiste and Cato.